FAIRWAY

Plum Street Garden Apartments

501 Plum St, Capitola, CA 95010

Property Summary

Located in the upper village of Capitola, this apartment community offers a quiet living environment with recent upgrades. The property features a courtyard and on-site laundry facilities. Residents benefit from a convenient location near local shops, dining, and educational institutions. Units vary in layout, with select homes offering private balconies or patios, fireplaces, and dedicated office spaces. The community is pet-friendly and provides flexible lease terms ranging from 6 to 12 months.

Renter brief

At the source check, 5 units were listed as available. That snapshot spanned studio to 2-bedroom homes. The lowest listed rent in that snapshot was $2,450/mo.

Source · Apartments.com · checked Nov 12, 2026

Available units

Checked 4 days ago

  • Studio · 1 ba · 376 ft² · Unit 18
    Available Now
    $2,450/mo
  • Studio · 1 ba · 376 ft² · Unit 34
    Available Now
    $2,500/mo
  • 1 bd · 1 ba · 610 ft² · Unit 30
    Available Now
    $2,995/mo
  • 2 bd · 1 ba · 800 ft² · Unit 48
    Available Now
    $3,200/mo

Amenities

  • Courtyard
  • Laundry Facilities

How the rent compares

This building, studio$2,450
Within 5 mi median$2,499

Source · 75 active studio units · Within 5 mi · 45-day window · computed Nov 16, 2026

Renter facts, criterion by criterion

No overall grade — each row reflects only the fact and source shown.

Rent comparisonAverage

Within 2% of the studio median within 5 mi

Source · 75 active studio units · Within 5 mi · 45-day window · computed Nov 16, 2026

Transit accessBelow average

19.6 mi straight-line distance to Morgan Hill Caltrain Northbound

Source · Transit map coordinates · not a routed trip

Building ageFact

Built in 1965

Source · Apartments.com · checked Nov 12, 2026

In-unit laundryNot offered

Shared laundry on site

Source · Apartments.com · checked Nov 12, 2026

What's Around

  • Transit
    Morgan Hill Caltrain Northbound · 19.6 mi straight-line
  • Groceries
    Grady's Market · 0.1 mi
  • Dining
    137 restaurants & cafés within 1 mi
  • Parks
    Monterey Park · 0.3 mi
  • University
    San Jose State University · 24.9 mi

Policies & Fees

Pet Policy
Dogs✓ Allowed
Cats✓ Allowed

Source · Apartments.com · checked Nov 12, 2026

Fees & Deposits
One-time fees
Application fee$40
Monthly fees
Storage$25/mo

Source · Apartments.com · checked Nov 12, 2026

Reviews

Review Summary
  • Residents appreciate the well-maintained grounds, attentive staff, and convenient location.
  • However, some potential renters reported negative experiences, including allegations of harassment and being scammed for fees.
  • 3.4 stars across 5 reviews.
H
Haley Georgalos
a year ago
Google
Plum Street Garden apartments has been a wonderful place to live. Their staff is on top of it and super helpful. Glenda Thomas, the new property manager, has been absolutely wonderful! Maintenance req...
S
Steve Shambaugh
7 years ago
Google
I really like Plum Street Garden Apartments.  My initial impression of the facility and the on-site staff is warm and welcoming.  The grounds are bright, colorful, and well maintained.  All sorts of p...

Questions renters ask about this building

Are pets allowed, and what do they cost?

The listing says cats are allowed; cat costs were not disclosed; dogs are allowed; dog costs were not disclosed.

Source · Apartments.com · checked Nov 12, 2026

Is there in-unit laundry?

The listing reports shared laundry; it does not list an installed in-unit washer/dryer.

Source · Apartments.com · checked Nov 12, 2026

How close is the nearest rail station?

Morgan Hill Caltrain Northbound is 19.6 mi away by straight-line distance; this is not a routed walking estimate.

Source · Transit map coordinates

Find similar