Apartments for rent in Otay Mesa-Nestor, priced and graded.

Median asking rent in Otay Mesa-Nestor is $2,525/mo. Current residents pay a median of $2,157/mo (Census estimate) — 12% below the San Diego average and 54% above the national one. 44% of the 68,224 people here rent. Fairway has 99 listings across 67 buildings in Otay Mesa-Nestor from 9 sources, refreshed continuously.

See rent by bedroom

How much is rent in Otay Mesa-Nestor?

A one-bedroom in Otay Mesa-Nestor runs $2,000/mo and a two-bedroom $2,600/mo, from Fairway's rental index.

No. of bedsMedian% of rentalsUnits availableFind places
Studio$1,450/mo3%3Find places →
1 Bedroom$2,000/mo27%26Find places →
2 Bedroom$2,600/mo50%48Find places →
3+ Bedroom$3,600/mo20%19Find places →

Medians: Fairway rental index for Otay Mesa-Nestor, computed Nov 2, 2026; bedroom sizes the index does not cover use live listings. Availability refreshed continuously.

Rent affordability
$/yr

Comfortable is the 30% rule; landlords here typically require 2.5–3× the monthly rent in gross income. Otay Mesa-Nestor's $2,525/mo median asking rent sits in your a stretch range.

Who rents in Otay Mesa-Nestor

Census Rent Data

Rent Distribution

How much residents in Otay Mesa-Nestor pay in rent (Census data).

Under $500
3%
$500–$999
5%
$1,000–$1,499
12%
$1,500–$1,999
32%
$2,000+
49%

Is Otay Mesa-Nestor a good place to live?

It depends on your priorities: Otay Mesa-Nestor grades C overall — strongest on parks, weakest on housing.

Neighborhood Grades

Powered byNiche
Public SchoolsC+
Cost of LivingD+
Safety—
NightlifeA-
Outdoor ActivitiesA-
WalkabilityB+

Compare Nearby Neighborhoods

NeighborhoodAsking rentBuildings availableOverall
San Ysidro$2,12849C-
Tijuana River Valley—0C+
Otay Mesa$2,99735B-
Barrio Logan$1,90015C+
Golden Hill$2,645108A-

Population

How many people live in Otay Mesa-Nestor.

Population68,224

Commute & Transportation

How residents of Otay Mesa-Nestor get to work.

Drive Alone71%
Walk/Bike1%
Work from Home8%

Housing Stock

Types of Housing

Housing type and age distribution in Otay Mesa-Nestor.

Home Types

Single Family
52%
Large Apt Building
16%
Small Apt Building
13%
Townhouse
10%
Mobile Home
9%

Home Age

2000–Present
10%
1980–1999
25%
1960–1979
53%
1940–1959
11%
Before 1939
1%

Schools

Elementary Schools (1)

B-

Ocean View Hills

K-5 · 1,020 students

22:1

Middle Schools (13)

B-

Myrtle S. Finney Elementary School

K-6 · 396 students

21:1
B-

Silver Wing Elementary School

K-6 · 335 students

22:1
B-

Montgomery Middle School

7-8 · 734 students

22:1
B-

Vista Del Mar

6-8 · 541 students

22:1
B-

Juarez-Lincoln Elementary School

K-6 · 426 students

22:1
C+

Mar Vista Academy

7-8 · 462 students

18:1
C+

Los Altos Elementary School

K-6 · 263 students

18:1
C

Southwest Middle School

7-8 · 515 students

21:1
C

Emory Elementary School

K-6 · 399 students

25:1
C-

Teofilo Mendoza

K-6 · 468 students

25:1
C-

Sunnyslope Elementary School

K-6 · 324 students

25:1
D+

Godfrey G. Berry Elementary School

K-6 · 273 students

25:1
D+

Howard Pence Elementary School

K-6 · 419 students

25:1

High Schools (4)

B

San Ysidro High School

9-12 · 1,941 students

23:1
B

Southwest Senior High School

9-12 · 1,563 students

22:1
B

Options Secondary School

7-12 · 69 students

7:1
B

Montgomery Senior High School

9-12 · 1,568 students

22:1

Renting in Otay Mesa-Nestor, explained

What is the average rent in Otay Mesa-Nestor?
The median asking rent in Otay Mesa-Nestor is $2,525/mo across 96 available listings in Fairway's index. Current residents pay a median of $2,157/mo (Census estimate), which includes long-held leases.
How much is a 1-bedroom vs a 2-bedroom in Otay Mesa-Nestor?
A one-bedroom in Otay Mesa-Nestor runs about $2,000/mo and a two-bedroom about $2,600/mo, from Fairway's rental index.
Is Otay Mesa-Nestor a good place to live?
It depends on your priorities: Otay Mesa-Nestor grades C overall — strongest on parks, weakest on housing.
What income do I need to rent in Otay Mesa-Nestor?
At the 30% rule, the $2,525/mo median asking rent in Otay Mesa-Nestor takes about $101,000 a year in gross income. Landlords typically ask for 2.5–3× the monthly rent.
How many people rent in Otay Mesa-Nestor?
44% of Otay Mesa-Nestor's 68,224 residents rent rather than own.
How many rentals are available in Otay Mesa-Nestor right now?
99 rentals are available in Otay Mesa-Nestor right now, 96 of them with a listed rent and bedroom count, across the 68 rental properties Fairway tracks there, refreshed continuously across our listing sources.
Is Otay Mesa-Nestor cheaper than the rest of San Diego?
By what current residents pay (Census estimates), Otay Mesa-Nestor's $2,157/mo median is 12% below the San Diego average; the comparison table above shows asking rents for 8 alternatives.

Free for renters · Otay Mesa-Nestor

Stop refreshing. Start moving in.

Describe the Otay Mesa-Nestor place you want. The AI searches every site, calls the properties, and books the tours.